29
Fri, Nov
0 New Articles

Judge: IBM Guilty of Age Discrimination

Commentary
Typography
  • Smaller Small Medium Big Bigger
  • Default Helvetica Segoe Georgia Times

Let's say you work for the greatest corporation on earth. You've devoted your career to developing its products, promoting its values, and helping it to achieve its goals. And let's say that the company has reciprocated with good pay, substantial incentives to remain within the organization, and promises of excellent health and retirement benefits. Does that sound like a recipe for success? Well, a lot of employees at IBM believed it was.

But then a little accounting change by Big Blue--a change that was destined to save the corporation billions of dollars--suddenly poisoned the brew for many within IBM, and the atmosphere has never been the same.

Pension Fund Switched; Employees Hurt

On July 31, Judge G. Patrick Murphy of the U.S. District Court in the Southern District of Illinois ruled that IBM had discriminated against its older workers in several ways when it converted its pension plan. Why? Because the changes left these employees with smaller benefits at retirement than younger workers would get when they eventually retired.

In 1995 and 1999, IBM switched its pension plan for employees. First, it switched the plan to a hybrid called a "pension equity plan," and then it converted to what is called a "cash-balance plan." The cash-balance plan combined some features of traditional pensions, but it melted many older workers' benefits (some employees claim as much as 50% while revoking lifetime medical insurance). The net effect was to provide older workers with less time than their younger colleagues to build up equity in the retirement scheme.

IEBAC Formed to Protest Actions

As a result of the employee uproar, the IBM Employee Benefits Action Coalition (IEBAC) was formed in June 1999. On November 1, 1999, IEBAC filed a class-action lawsuit against IBM, representing 130,000 current and former IBM employees. Then, in February 2000, IEBAC sent an open letter to SEC Active Chairman Laura Simone Unger, detailing how IBM was using the pension fund savings to bolster its annual report of financial earnings before shareholders. According to the allegations, IBM showed the profits accruing in the employee pension fund as corporate profits, while neglecting to show that the pension actually belonged to the employees and retirees.

IEBAC's actions led to an email campaign in May 2001 to encourage congressmen to co-sponsor HR 1322: Emergency Retiree Health Benefits Protection Act, proposed by Congressman John Tierney (D-Massachusetts). The bill was designed to restrict corporations from using pension funds in unethical ways. This bill was reintroduced in 2003 and is currently in committee. Since then, several other bills have been introduced to restrict the ways by which pension funds can be manipulated. Also, the uproar has forced the Internal Revenue Service to impose a moratorium on new conversions of pension funds to cash-balance plans.

Corporate Pension Fund Practices

IBM's accounting of pension funds in its annual report is not an unusual practice by large corporations, and--in response to IEBAC's open letter--IBM said that it needed to include the earnings of the pension fund in its report in order to maintain its competitive stance in the valuation of its stock. However, without also indicating the lien against the pension by current employees and retirees, the net effect is to inflate earnings. Senior executive bonuses and stock options--such as those earned by Lou Gerstner during his tenure as CEO and Chairman--are directly tied to the performance of IBM stock on an annual basis. By inflating the annual report and meeting or exceeding analyst expectations, stock prices will rise, making the executives stock options more valuable. By changing the extent of pension liabilities through a cash-balance plan, the corporation also increases its projected long-term profitability, thereby increasing its stock value.

Ruling Impacts All Cash-Balance Pensions

If the ruling of Judge Murphy is upheld, many legal scholars believe that all cash-balance plans will be viewed as age discrimination. However, the IRS is already writing guidelines for cash-balance conversions. According to analysts who have been following the case, the IRS believes that cash-balance pension plans are not inherently discriminatory and can be designed to treat older workers fairly.

During the ongoing IT recession, concerns about pension and retirement have weighed heavily upon IT professionals, and older IBM employees are not the only ones: The actions of IEBAC fostered the support of the Association of Bell Retirees as well. Meanwhile, a bill that would allow corporations to legally under-fund pensions (HR 1776: Pension Preservation and Savings Expansion Act of 2003) has also been introduced into the house.

IBM Pension Fails the Test

Judge Murphy, in his ruling, considered whether IBM's actions in changing its pension plan treated employees equitably by looking at the amount of benefits older and younger workers would have earned by the time they retired. According to Judge Murphy, both the cash-balance model and the pension equity plan failed in this regard.

In both of IBM's plans, younger employees have many years to build up their benefits, according to the judge. But employees who are close to retirement age when the pension plan is converted have only a few years and therefore cannot earn as much. In addition, Judge Murphy disclosed that IBM's calculations had either worsened the effect on older workers or given advantages to younger employees. One of the problems noted by the Judge was the calculation of the benefit amount each worker had earned under the traditional pension plan at the time it was converted. Judge Murphy said that IBM dealt with the period of time when the new pension plan had been adopted, but some employees, in effect, earned no new benefits.

IEBAC Vindicated

Janet Krueger, an organizer of IEBAC, a former IBM employee, current treasurer of the COMMON user group, and recognized expert in IBM iSeries computing, was quoted after Judge Murphy's ruling: "In some ways, I feel exonerated because I've had so many people telling me that IBM didn't really do anything wrong, and you shouldn't be wasting your time."

IBM Will Appeal

Meanwhile, IBM has announced that it will appeal Judge Murphy's ruling. In a press release on July 31, 2003, IBM said: "Under the court's interpretation of the law, every cash-balance plan in the country is illegal. Scores of Fortune 500 companies have such plans.... The court's reasoning...is contrary to the decision of two other district courts which uphold cash-balance plans as lawful."

What's Fair and What's Business as Usual

At the heart of the dispute, however, is not what is legal under the law but what's fair to employees who made plans based upon promises that IBM made to their employees. Common wisdom credits the leadership of former CEO and Chairman Lou Gerstner in the turnaround of IBM's fortunes during the 1990s.

However, during that period, great numbers of IBM employees left the organization, and IBM was faced with a daunting challenge: save the sinking ship or save the crew on board. IBM went through a number of reorganizations designed to winnow out which positions within the corporation would be saved and which positions would be eliminated. For those who were faced with "early retirement," part of their decision whether to stay or go included the benefits they had accrued. When IBM subsequently changed the value of those benefits, many IBMers who chose to stay felt betrayed.

In addition, while the Chairman/CEO's fortunes--along with other IBM executives'--were raised in proportion to the corporation's stock recovery, IBM employees and line managers suddenly saw their retirement pensions recast as "cash assets" on the company's books. Documents released during the trial showed that some of the assets of the employee pension fund were actually reassigned to fund a separate executive pension plan.

IBM's current leadership, under Sam Palmisano, has attempted to change this executive culture. Palmisano recently cut the executive committees within IBM and has asked the corporation's board to reallocate his potential multi-million dollar bonus to be divided among the working team of executives that he has assembled. His goal is to re-invigorate the sense of teamwork that once typified IBM.

But for former IBM employees who have retired or left the company, the new spirit within IBM is not about "business as usual" today but what was promised to them in the past and what is fair and right.

Thomas M. Stockwell is Editor in Chief of MC Press. He may be reached for comment at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

Thomas Stockwell

Thomas M. Stockwell is an independent IT analyst and writer. He is the former Editor in Chief of MC Press Online and Midrange Computing magazine and has over 20 years of experience as a programmer, systems engineer, IT director, industry analyst, author, speaker, consultant, and editor.  

 

Tom works from his home in the Napa Valley in California. He can be reached at ITincendiary.com.

 

 

BLOG COMMENTS POWERED BY DISQUS

LATEST COMMENTS

Support MC Press Online

$

Book Reviews

Resource Center

  • SB Profound WC 5536 Have you been wondering about Node.js? Our free Node.js Webinar Series takes you from total beginner to creating a fully-functional IBM i Node.js business application. You can find Part 1 here. In Part 2 of our free Node.js Webinar Series, Brian May teaches you the different tooling options available for writing code, debugging, and using Git for version control. Brian will briefly discuss the different tools available, and demonstrate his preferred setup for Node development on IBM i or any platform. Attend this webinar to learn:

  • SB Profound WP 5539More than ever, there is a demand for IT to deliver innovation. Your IBM i has been an essential part of your business operations for years. However, your organization may struggle to maintain the current system and implement new projects. The thousands of customers we've worked with and surveyed state that expectations regarding the digital footprint and vision of the company are not aligned with the current IT environment.

  • SB HelpSystems ROBOT Generic IBM announced the E1080 servers using the latest Power10 processor in September 2021. The most powerful processor from IBM to date, Power10 is designed to handle the demands of doing business in today’s high-tech atmosphere, including running cloud applications, supporting big data, and managing AI workloads. But what does Power10 mean for your data center? In this recorded webinar, IBMers Dan Sundt and Dylan Boday join IBM Power Champion Tom Huntington for a discussion on why Power10 technology is the right strategic investment if you run IBM i, AIX, or Linux. In this action-packed hour, Tom will share trends from the IBM i and AIX user communities while Dan and Dylan dive into the tech specs for key hardware, including:

  • Magic MarkTRY the one package that solves all your document design and printing challenges on all your platforms. Produce bar code labels, electronic forms, ad hoc reports, and RFID tags – without programming! MarkMagic is the only document design and print solution that combines report writing, WYSIWYG label and forms design, and conditional printing in one integrated product. Make sure your data survives when catastrophe hits. Request your trial now!  Request Now.

  • SB HelpSystems ROBOT GenericForms of ransomware has been around for over 30 years, and with more and more organizations suffering attacks each year, it continues to endure. What has made ransomware such a durable threat and what is the best way to combat it? In order to prevent ransomware, organizations must first understand how it works.

  • SB HelpSystems ROBOT GenericIT security is a top priority for businesses around the world, but most IBM i pros don’t know where to begin—and most cybersecurity experts don’t know IBM i. In this session, Robin Tatam explores the business impact of lax IBM i security, the top vulnerabilities putting IBM i at risk, and the steps you can take to protect your organization. If you’re looking to avoid unexpected downtime or corrupted data, you don’t want to miss this session.

  • SB HelpSystems ROBOT GenericCan you trust all of your users all of the time? A typical end user receives 16 malicious emails each month, but only 17 percent of these phishing campaigns are reported to IT. Once an attack is underway, most organizations won’t discover the breach until six months later. A staggering amount of damage can occur in that time. Despite these risks, 93 percent of organizations are leaving their IBM i systems vulnerable to cybercrime. In this on-demand webinar, IBM i security experts Robin Tatam and Sandi Moore will reveal:

  • FORTRA Disaster protection is vital to every business. Yet, it often consists of patched together procedures that are prone to error. From automatic backups to data encryption to media management, Robot automates the routine (yet often complex) tasks of iSeries backup and recovery, saving you time and money and making the process safer and more reliable. Automate your backups with the Robot Backup and Recovery Solution. Key features include:

  • FORTRAManaging messages on your IBM i can be more than a full-time job if you have to do it manually. Messages need a response and resources must be monitored—often over multiple systems and across platforms. How can you be sure you won’t miss important system events? Automate your message center with the Robot Message Management Solution. Key features include:

  • FORTRAThe thought of printing, distributing, and storing iSeries reports manually may reduce you to tears. Paper and labor costs associated with report generation can spiral out of control. Mountains of paper threaten to swamp your files. Robot automates report bursting, distribution, bundling, and archiving, and offers secure, selective online report viewing. Manage your reports with the Robot Report Management Solution. Key features include:

  • FORTRAFor over 30 years, Robot has been a leader in systems management for IBM i. With batch job creation and scheduling at its core, the Robot Job Scheduling Solution reduces the opportunity for human error and helps you maintain service levels, automating even the biggest, most complex runbooks. Manage your job schedule with the Robot Job Scheduling Solution. Key features include:

  • LANSA Business users want new applications now. Market and regulatory pressures require faster application updates and delivery into production. Your IBM i developers may be approaching retirement, and you see no sure way to fill their positions with experienced developers. In addition, you may be caught between maintaining your existing applications and the uncertainty of moving to something new.

  • LANSAWhen it comes to creating your business applications, there are hundreds of coding platforms and programming languages to choose from. These options range from very complex traditional programming languages to Low-Code platforms where sometimes no traditional coding experience is needed. Download our whitepaper, The Power of Writing Code in a Low-Code Solution, and:

  • LANSASupply Chain is becoming increasingly complex and unpredictable. From raw materials for manufacturing to food supply chains, the journey from source to production to delivery to consumers is marred with inefficiencies, manual processes, shortages, recalls, counterfeits, and scandals. In this webinar, we discuss how:

  • The MC Resource Centers bring you the widest selection of white papers, trial software, and on-demand webcasts for you to choose from. >> Review the list of White Papers, Trial Software or On-Demand Webcast at the MC Press Resource Center. >> Add the items to yru Cart and complet he checkout process and submit

  • Profound Logic Have you been wondering about Node.js? Our free Node.js Webinar Series takes you from total beginner to creating a fully-functional IBM i Node.js business application.

  • SB Profound WC 5536Join us for this hour-long webcast that will explore:

  • Fortra IT managers hoping to find new IBM i talent are discovering that the pool of experienced RPG programmers and operators or administrators with intimate knowledge of the operating system and the applications that run on it is small. This begs the question: How will you manage the platform that supports such a big part of your business? This guide offers strategies and software suggestions to help you plan IT staffing and resources and smooth the transition after your AS/400 talent retires. Read on to learn: